Fletcher90 23 posts 7 months old |
on 03-01-2025 17:20:58 (3 weeks ago) Player market is currently full of overpriced offers for players, which noone buying. To avoid people to put player in market just if someone want to pay huge amount, I suggest to charge 10% tax on initial bid price as fee for sending on market. In case player is sold, initial tax will be deducted from total tax. In case player is not sold, tax money will not be returned. Benefit: players will have lower starting price and more bidding will happened. |
Adrian09 93 posts 7 months old |
on 03-01-2025 18:15:55 (3 weeks ago) This will just kill for good the market/ |
Mmm 55 posts 4 months old |
on 03-01-2025 18:25:31 (3 weeks ago) _200 |
Borubar 18 posts 7 months old |
on 03-01-2025 18:44:49 (3 weeks ago) Or just ignore the overpriced offers like everyone else... |
Momo025 26 posts 7 months old |
on 03-01-2025 18:52:50 (3 weeks ago) Byyyy -$ |
JUmpingJAckFLash14 97 posts 7 months old |
on 03-01-2025 19:45:38 (3 weeks ago) yes market is not interesting and nothing happened :/
|
Fletcher90 23 posts 7 months old |
on 03-01-2025 20:02:01 (3 weeks ago) Adrian09, in my opinion, market is already killed, just with many overpriced offers, people don't realise it. My suggestion is first to clean it, than try to revive. How to revive is different story, usually players needs to be burden to sell them, which means maybe raise of salaries can be solution. On other hand, necessity of buying can also increase market activities. For example, players can be injured for longer period ( bigger roster required), players lose condition more, players unable to play more than 1 game per day (quite radical)
|
maridiba 148 posts 7 months old |
on 03-01-2025 21:36:19 (3 weeks ago) I like this proposal, I've also tried to propose it in the first seasons of KOB because that's a common practice in online football manager games: it costs nothing if the player is sold because the initial cost is deducted when paying the final tax, but it keeps the market clean. In this kind of game, I usually like to build my team with training and I typically look for young stars to buy and train for my team, but in KOB I stopped browsing the market because it's flooded with useless overpriced players. I usually make bids when I find a good player advertised on Discord, but this change would finally make the market efficient also from a buyer's perspective. edited on 03-01-2025 21:46:38 (1 times)
|
Landlord 75 posts 7 months old |
on 04-01-2025 00:08:16 (3 weeks ago) I said stuff on discord suggestion over the current market Performance thus this prepositions in my understanding will Futher push the market in negatives. Do the one making this Suggestion realised prices of players 52 to 58 AQ back then In 2nd to 3rd season were over 20 to 100 euros?? And today those Players with such AQ are been sold way less. Such that If you bought players Couple of season back then from the market and train them, improve their AQ and finally put them on transfer market to sell them at age 20 to 25 Which should be prime yrs for most players, do you realised you will be Unable to sell the player same value bought in the market 2 to 3 season ago? Eg, 54 AQ defender I bought 9 euros 3 season ago is now 57 AQ but non is bidding on Him for 5 euros and he is just 21.... You sure don't want to push the price of player down with more taxing, you'll soon One day shift from consumer to seller and realise you can't make profit from Selling players you spend so much on, to sign from youth, train for months and End up selling way beyond under the worth and time put into the player.... edited on 04-01-2025 00:21:55 (4 times)
|
maridiba 148 posts 7 months old |
on 04-01-2025 09:20:41 (3 weeks ago) Nobody is proposing to raise taxes, it would still be 10%... the only difference is that the seller saves 1 local currency that is currently paid to list a player. Taxes have nothing to do with the decrease in the value of the player of your example. Keep in mind that you are not the only one who can train players: when your player's skills increase, also the skills of other players increase according to how well they train; a young player can gain or lose value over time based on the quality of the training ground and coaches, and also based on which skills are raised. Check my player Ion Vladut, bought 5 seasons ago for 4€, and now he has 62 AQ and can play well in Italian League A. I'm not interested in selling him, but his value is probably higher than 4€ now. You can't expect to sell your players for a higher price if they get older without a substantial skill increase |
Fletcher90 23 posts 7 months old |
on 04-01-2025 10:44:19 (3 weeks ago) As Maridiba said, I was not proposing any additional tax, just mechanism to avoid putting bad players on high price. Currently, I can put whole my team on market with price 100eur+ for max 1g fee and waiting that someone mistaken and bid. If I need to pay 10eur initially for each I put for 100eur, I will not do it, or I will do it only for top player that will be sold |
Adrian09 93 posts 7 months old |
on 04-01-2025 10:57:10 (3 weeks ago) Well, you have a nice filter options right now, so, you can see only players which fits your needs, but about price, everyone is free to ask as much as he wants, if you consider that price "overpriced", dont buy, but for seller, that might be normal price. It is all related to seller, if he needs fast money, he will lower price untill it sells, if he dont, he can hold same player over and over and in most cases, it will sell even at an "overpriced" price. Its funny, most of you probably want to buy well skilled players close to cost to spawn it or even lower. Market its fine, you can find legit, right now, players close to their spawn price and beeing trained for months, wjhat you want more? Want them for 50% of their value? Personally, i would rather end with them in my team untill they retire then selling as an example a 5 star player trained for months for 50-80E as they do now. ANd anyway, if you think they are overpriced, you can ALWAYS spawn new ones and train them, cheaper, ofc, it takes take but it is what it is, pay or go cheaper way.
PS: When most of teams who aimed to build best team bought best players at a way higher price then nowaday prices, havent seen any seller/buying crying around that prices are too high, but now, when some of them or other managers looking to build a similar team moaming around to reduce their price more. edited on 04-01-2025 11:05:16 (1 times)
|
Fletcher90 23 posts 7 months old |
on 04-01-2025 12:20:52 (3 weeks ago) Adrian09, you miss my point, I don't mind if people put any price in player market, I just wanted to be properly charged for it, not only 1 local currency. Putting initial price should be important decision, not irrelevant like it is now.
|
Landlord 75 posts 7 months old |
on 04-01-2025 14:34:44 (3 weeks ago) Maybe good idea after all.. +1 |
Adrian09 93 posts 7 months old |
on 04-01-2025 16:14:35 (3 weeks ago) @fletcher90 , i see your suggestion: "Player market is currently full of overpriced offers for players, which noone buying. To avoid people to put player in market just if someone want to pay huge amount, I suggest to charge 10% tax on initial bid price as fee for sending on market. In case player is sold, initial tax will be deducted from total tax. In case player is not sold, tax money will not be returned. Benefit: players will have lower starting price and more bidding will happened." So, you want everyone to be taxed with 10% ofr initial asking price despite of having it sold or not, which, its just a shit update which will just ruin market at all and turn it into a forum spam. THere are already fees, adding more dont solve the issue but will just ruin it more. personally, i dont mind having players listed even for 1000Euro, i can just set my own filters and thats it :) |
Mmm 55 posts 4 months old |
on 04-01-2025 20:13:54 (3 weeks ago) @everyone I don't think add 10% tasks to every selling price of any player will really help to reduce over pricing in the player market, what I think should be done is... |