Hi everyone,

I am fairly new and wanted to make sure I understand how everything works so I can play 100% by the rules.

I just added a second team to my account. I have a question about the Youth Center. Let's say Team A spawns a young player from the academy, but it is a duplicate role that I don't need on that squad. However, that specific position would be very useful for Team B.

Is it against the rules if Team B buys this academy player directly from Team A? Since both teams belong to my account, does the game allow direct transfers like this, or is it considered a violation?

Also, can someone please confirm if it is allowed to withdraw Platinum from Team A into the President's fund, and then deposit that same Platinum into Team B?

I want to make sure I don't break any market rules or risk getting banned. Thanks for your help!

So far i know its not possible to let put players from A to B or B to A.

if its possible sell player to friend and friend sell it to you.

if that construction leads to a ban, i dont know.

maybe Nicmo can say something about it.ce

on other hand its legal let play friendlies to eachother and let play both your youth using youth league

however i dont know if its ever indirectly buy a player from eachother example if player is several sold from teams and your first or second team buy it when its for example old

as I Saïd maybe Nicmo can say something about it, hoever buying on such say can be somewhat more expensive

I am not sure why is forbiden to sell from your team to your another team. Still taxes needs to be paid, everyone is allow to bid, and if you use to transfer money, it is easier to transfer through manager account.

@Nicmo, maybe you can explain rationals behind?

I guess only due to option to bid higher as majority of money come back to your account

One of the main reasons you can't sell directly to self is to prevent a player from playing important matches in both teams during the same season.

Thanks @nicmo, that makes perfect sense! Since I was referring to academy players I didn't think about the competitive aspect of a player featuring in key matches for both squads.

I guess there is probably an economic reason too, since trading academy players directly between Team A and Team B doesn't inject new liquidity into the game's economy.

Just to be 100% sure before I make any moves, could you please confirm if it is allowed to transfer funds from one club to the other by going through the Manager's balance? (i.e., withdrawing from Team A to the Manager, and then depositing from the Manager into Team B).

Thanks again for the help!

nicmo

One of the main reasons you can't sell directly to self is to prevent a player from playing important matches in both teams during the same season.

@nicmo

this still can happen

player A team sells to friend. Friend sells player to B team

this can be done in 48 hours, just setting transfer on 24h. Its not directly but indirectly.

dont know if that trick is legal.

anyway didnt do that so far, but it can handy give a youth from A team to B team

yes this costs Some little more but is still possible I think

i havent tried this Anyway so far

Thuru

@nicmo

this still can happen

player A team sells to friend. Friend sells player to B team

this can be done in 48 hours, just setting transfer on 24h. Its not directly but indirectly.

dont know if that trick is legal.

anyway didnt do that so far, but it can handy give a youth from A team to B team

yes this costs Some little more but is still possible I think

i havent tried this Anyway so far

@Thuru

I believe that, in this particular case, it may not become a significant issue. Although, of course, there is no guarantee.

Such transactions would generate additional tax revenue for the game while also introducing the risk that the player could be purchased by another club. Furthermore, because of the auto-bid system, completing a transfer at the minimum price would be extremely difficult, especially for high quality player.

nicmo

One of the main reasons you can't sell directly to self is to prevent a player from playing important matches in both teams during the same season.

@nicmo

To further reduce the potential for abuse, I suggest implementing an additional restriction: if a manager owns two teams, they should only be allowed to buy a player from one of their own teams after that player has been transferred to at least two different clubs or has spent one to two full seasons playing for another club  This would make it much more difficult to use multiple clubs to bypass the intended transfer system while still allowing legitimate transfers under controlled conditions.