I think the game should have tactics for each sector, that is, we can put strikers, midfielders and defenders to play depending on how we want to play.

for example:

attackers
attack only / help defend / help the midfield

midfielders
keep positions / press the front / help defend

defenses
only defend / defenses go attack / support the midfield

1 ++++

Good suggestion

however weak trams always go to degeneratie, try pick a point

Nic can avoid all my suggestions but as time goes on the urge 

For better tactical option will grow bigger and would discourage 

Players that is familiar with football management having used to

Be In control of giving many instructions to control the match

To now be limited to one formation and some little option like

Middle area or play from flanks. Sometime i use play in center area

Of the pitch and my players like lm and rm ended up scoring each on

That game gave me the idea maybe playing through the center isn't same

The tactical option like wildth  that allow us to adjustment the wildness to

Play more on Flanks or  norrow it down to focus on middle. That's different 

From pass focus of course where your instructed team to play center or side

To pass more to. And that's the good combinations if such tactical option are available

And managers with better idea of football management can tweaks and blend the 

Playing style of his team. 

Also that should be capital area you should place formation experiences on for example:

A club that has played wild for over five match, play pass in the space which i understand should

Somewhat the same idea of through ball. Which could be better if ( option like short or long ball) is 

Added, close down or any time the marking is changed some percentage of formation bonus is lot.

And same goes to team that play wild switching to play center, and from passing in space to shoot

On sight also lose percentage of playing familiarity which made up for formation bonuses. 

The idea of 1 formation all season is far from realistic :) 

And as Nick suggested that formation star bonus should be removed:

His reason were that club in champion league gain more stars than

Clubs that compete in local league. But the other way round; i lost twice

In champion league in row last seaon breaking down my moral building

That made me struggle in local competition. i would care less if i had the 

Entire option to switch formation without losing stars at the other end.

I could perform better watching my next opponent closely and step in the

Game with right formation. Playing in both international and local competitions

With same formation makes me want to think this whole game is a setup for

Whatever lucky win  comes to me. Club of similar strength only advantage comes

From better tactical instruction, and if because i use 433 in champion league due

To the kind of formation opponents use in the competition and then have to stick

To 433 in local competitions where most club use default 442 that my 433 is weak

Weak against but anyway i have to force it through or chose another formation where

I now have to struggle to keep 433 stars bonus for international competitions and the

New formation with 1 star bonus can be abuse with club that have similar strengths

Whilst they have 5 stars formation bonus. This is very important part of football.

Give managers formation freedom or at least something better than this. Thank you.